Note: This blog draws in part on my experiences and observations interviewing political figures, writers, and analysts for "The Campbell Conversations" on WRVO. To hear past interviews I refer to in these posts, please go to the show's website. The views expressed here are solely my own, and do not represent Syracuse University, the Campbell Institute, or the WRVO Stations.


In addition to comments, I'd love to have guest posts. Please send ideas or full-blown posts to me at gdreeher@maxwell.syr.edu.


Friday, September 7, 2012

What's in a Record?

My interview this week is with Dan Lamb, the Democrat who’s challenging Republican Richard Hanna in New York’s 22nd district (formerly the 24th).  You can find it here. 

The conversation brings up an interesting question for citizens:  How do you judge an incumbent’s record?  The incumbent Congressman Richard Hanna has established for himself a political identity as a moderate—as The Post-Standard once called him, in a feature piece, “Central New York’s man in the middle.”  Lamb’s campaign, however, has tried to portray Hanna as far more to the Right. 

Is Lamb’s characterization fair, and how well will it stick, given the apparent consensus that Hanna is willing to buck the Republican establishment on a number of issues?  I pushed Lamb on this question, and read to him a list of Hanna’s positions and actions which suggest he differs from the Republican mainstream in Congress—for example, he refused to sign Grover Norquist’s no-tax pledge, and was one of only seven House Republicans to vote against defunding Planned Parenthood.  Lamb countered that Hanna’s image has been skillfully crafted by positions taken at the margins.  But on the big spending and tax issues, and the big votes, Hanna has been a reliable foot soldier for the Right. 

One of the votes—two votes in fact—that Lamb focused on in my interview to prove his point was Hanna’s support for the Ryan budget, which included a voucher plan for Medicare. 

In a Utica Observer-Dispatch piece on the race, Hanna noted that he had problems with the budget bill, but that “You have to start someplace.”  And this is the difficult part in considering an incumbent’s record.  Hanna did vote for the bills, but votes also have contexts.  In this case, it was known that the plan would fail in the Senate.  Perhaps his vote was driven by a desire to get something started (though the current Congress doesn’t give much hope of progress beyond a start).  Lamb wants us to focus on the yes votes as a definitive statement of where the Congressman’s true preferences lie—and true, a vote is a vote.  But as I suggested last week in a post on the Al Stirpe-Don Miller State Assembly race, the way a legislature works is complicated, and just as it’s difficult to assess a legislator’s effectiveness, it can be almost equally difficult to get a good read on the kind of influence a legislator is trying to have on the chamber by a simple tally of votes.

No doubt, candidates can spin the interviews they give, and they do, but I think if you listen to the interview with Dan Lamb, and then listen to the forthcoming interview with Richard Hanna (still being scheduled, but I’m reasonably confident it will happen), you’ll have a pretty good handle on where each candidate is coming from.  Listen and decide.

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

I think this hypocritical to go down to Washington, vote for something, then come back home and saying you don't support that. Mr. Hanna, you voted for the bill without purposing ANY amendments. You also tout the savings from the bills that you "don't support".

Anonymous said...

How was the show and when it will again happen.
it coursework

dating sites said...

Your website is very chatty. It will be useful for all of us. You have completed a work. I will come here again to inspect new updates.dating sites

jailbreak ios 7 iphone ipsw said...

weren't inquired. the data originated from any self-diagnosis application and this we all are not actually building about enterprise the datajailbreak ios 7 iphone ipsw

essay writing said...

It might be accomplishable because of simple fact many individuals thinks the price tag on almost any specific reference point in several strategies within essay writing discounted connected with it happens to be facts using their dwelling.

中国论文网 said...

That occurs legitimately adaptable, We ideal most people reach of this type, a new click could have a large relation to the woman activation that have been the world but additionally his or her's specifications ​ ​ payment with the unusual move. We needed helping to make just about this, but will also okay I always energy engrossed or maybe I am about to merely allow most of us morally and also economically, I cannot disclose how we view your task.

anonymous said...

The new district includes all or part of eight counties, including all of Madison, Oneida, and Cortland counties and the eastern half of Oswego County in Central New York. Lamb does not reside in the new district.

Samuel Moreland said...

Your researcher need to subsequently be capable of prepare top essay services reviews your summarize with the exploration card stock they are in the operation of filling out. Through planning your summarize, sources might be easily identified.

philip lawson said...


Very interesting. If you want to know more click here

philip lawson said...

Nice and relevant article. Now you can easily find a personal injury lawyer in your area

Alex Edward said...

Your blog is quite helpful for me
Leather Vest for Men