Note: This blog draws in part on my experiences and observations interviewing political figures, writers, and analysts for "The Campbell Conversations" on WRVO. To hear past interviews I refer to in these posts, please go to the show's website. The views expressed here are solely my own, and do not represent Syracuse University, the Campbell Institute, or the WRVO Stations.


In addition to comments, I'd love to have guest posts. Please send ideas or full-blown posts to me at gdreeher@maxwell.syr.edu.


Thursday, February 9, 2012

Presidents on a Roll?

It's hard to make generalizations about presidential administrations because there are relatively few cases in any given era, but they are on the verge of doing something that hasn't been done since the Monroe administration, and it has left me wondering what it might mean (if anything).

If the economy continues to turn around--which it is beginning to show signs of doing--and if presumptive Republican nominee Mitt Romney continues to offer a solid but uninspiring challenge to President Obama, it's likely that the president will be re-elected. 

And if that happens, it will be the first time since Jefferson-Madison-Monroe that three presidents in a row have sought and been re-elected to a second term.  The trio of Roosevelt-Truman-Eisenhower is the closest second, with FDR himself being re-elected three times and Truman serving most of Roosevelt's fourth term before being elected in his own right, but he did not stand for re-election in 1952, and probably would not have survived a challenge from IKE. 

It's even more interesting to note that Jefferson-Madison-Monroe were all in the same "Democratic-Republican" Party, while our recent three are far more diverse.  Clinton and Obama can each stake a claim to be centrists or moderates in their party--especially Clinton--but they are clearly cut from a different cloth than Bush. 

What does this mean?  Is it just coincidence?  Is it now harder somehow to beat an incumbent president?  Bush certainly seemed beatable in 2003, but in the end he was tough to dislodge.  Does it reflect something about our polarized politics?  Hypotheses welcome.

36 comments:

Mike said...

I think it is not likely a coincidence. It's more likely a combination of several causes:

1. Incumbents have advantages in money, organization, bully pulpit, and name recognition.

2. The quality of challengers put forth by the out-of-power party has been less than stellar (Dole, Kerry, anyone from the GOP this year).

3. The American people are less civic-minded and more jaded about politics, in general.

4. Fox News has become a force that likely made the re-election of an unpopular G. W. Bush popular and could be the factor if Obama is upset by the eventual weak GOP nominee.

Anonymous said...

No doubt, candidates can spin the interviews they give, and they do, but I think if you listen to the interview with Dan Lamb, and then listen to the forthcoming interview with Richard Hanna (still being scheduled, but I’m reasonably confident it will happen), you’ll have a pretty good handle http://www.essayontime.com/ on where each candidate is coming from. Listen and decide.

Anonymous said...

appreciate the effort of government in making ways to professional research paper make tax payment easier for taxpayers. That's why the government.

www.writemy-essay.com said...

"The American people are less civic-minded and more jaded about politics, in general" - I don't agree with that, last few years american people are more passive about politics

essay writing services said...

Superb article ,I really appreciated with it, This is fine to read and valuable pro potential,I really bookmark it, pro broaden read. Appreciation pro sharing. I like it

www.plagiarismdetect.com said...

"The American people are less civic-minded and more jaded about politics, in general" - I don't agree with that, last few years american people are more passive about politics

I think another way

Quality iBeacons Online said...

The Internet is huge. No one will deny that, and the role it plays in business is becoming more and more important as well. If you are looking to drive more traffic to your website, increase sales or just want to get your message out there,Quality iBeacons Online

plano invisalign dentist said...

this awesome blog are literally wonderful in addition as considering the very fact that filled with normal rock. Do stating and conjointly this surely i'll fully modify your blog. hope u well there. thanks plano invisalign dentist

Stephen Mando said...

All the things weather it is related to economy or other it depends to the president. Law dissertation help

rumah dijual di batununggal bandung said...

I simply get a crucial information right here and additionally this is often really Maine I trying. because of your current posting rumah dijual di batununggal bandung

Seagrove Beach said...

Well explained logic, that's true and must be followed for best outputs to have a brilliant experience for future assistance Seagrove Beach

Watercolor Paintings for sale said...

evista de Ciencia Política de la Universidad Católica de Chile titulado “Repensando la cuestión democrática: la región andina en el nuevo siglo”¹, en el cual se hacen interesantes comparaciones sobre el carácter democrático en los países de la región.Watercolor Paintings for sale

surf camp Portugal said...

I am an Easton primarily based Executive Technologies masteral having a substantial amount of time to yourself with my own hands at this time therefore sooo want to get involved!surf camp Portugal

capilar said...

llo there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it's really informative. I'm gonna watch out for brussels. I will appreciate if you continue this in future. Lots of people will be benefited from your writing.capilar

performance improvement said...

I am planning to decide on a career move and this has helped me with one aspect. Thanks man performance improvement

Watercolor Paintings said...

It is always hard to remember the past. Previously it was before. Time is different. But thank you for that because you write Watercolor Paintings

Alex Edward said...

Another great post from your side
Bane Vest

Pass bee Media said...

Weight-loss Issue covers taboos concerned with weight loss, weight loss testimonies, weight loss physical exercises, eating routine and will be offering an interactive software for you that will desires to are living a normal life.

kerosene heater said...

This is my first visit to your blog. We are starting a brand new initiative in the same category as this blog. Your blog provided us with important information to work with. You have done a great job.kerosene heater

Long term Disability insurance Attorney said...

The web is actually big. No-one will probably deny of which, and also the part this Long term Disability insurance Attorney performs in operation is actually becoming a lot more crucial also. For anyone who is looking to generate more site visitors aimed at your website, increase revenue or want to get your concept out there.

rumah dijual di batununggal bandung said...

That's something I'll have to look into for you. Give me a little while to research it and I'll let you know. If you can tell me what you are looking for and what time frame that will help me find the right person for you. rumah dijual di batununggal bandung

kerosene heater said...

I have bookmarked your blog, the articles are way better than other similar blogs.. thanks for a great blog!kerosene heater

Alex Edward said...

i really like your post it is quite informative
How to Dress Like Brad Pitt

driveway motion sensor said...

Fairly comically they're going on are convinced that "current Silk regulation stipulates the capabilities from the armed forces and government bodies in situations where the armed service will use pressure, arrest or perhaps detain.driveway motion sensor

plug in wireless door chime said...

Fairly comically they're going on are convinced that "current Silk regulation stipulates the capabilities from the armed forces and government bodies in situations where the armed service will use pressure, arrest or perhaps detain.plug in wireless door chime

Paris corporate event said...

Thanks for this post! Very interesting....I didn't even know these kinds of classes were offered! I've been wanting to take some writing courses to improve and make contacts but was not sure where to look. There really aren't any in my local area so online classes, Paris corporate event

website design agency denver said...

than ever before. Intended for my own website I would like the very best web page design and also web host company therefore.website design agency denver

Wayfair coupon said...

I don't think hovering helicopter parents do their children any favors. When are they supposed to learn to stand on their own two feet, and succeed based on their own achievementsWayfair coupon

​Best hologram said...

Wonderful post. I am searching awesome news and idea. What I have found from your site, it is actually highly content. You have spent long time for this post.

steps in selling a business said...

transitions mobility and elevator specializes in residential and commercial elevators, wheelchair platform lifts, auto lifts, stair lifts, patient transfer lifts, bath lifts, pool lifts, dumbwaiters, ramps, and replacement parts.steps in selling a business

Lawn Care said...

I enjoyed alot reading this post. It is instructive, comprehensive and to the point. Well done and thanks.Lawn Care

Vanessa said...

I think that your viewpoint is deep. I would recommend it to my friends, and hopefully this article useful to those who read it. Thanks.
essay writers uk

How apple pay works with passbook? said...

It is always hard to remember the past. Previously it was before. Time is different. But thank you for that because you write

surf camp UK said...

World's Most Popular Cars, Hot Speed Cars, Hot Cars with Hot Girls, Cars Latest Pictures with all info, Latest updates Cars Models and Company Cars, Strange Vehicles, Concept Cars, Top 10 Expensive Cars in the World.surf camp UK

davids said...

Sell your junk car for cash with we buy junk cars orlando

steve7876 said...

The only sad part about moving away from Maryland recently, was having to leave ProFIT. Now in my search for a new Zumba class, iWebHostingCoupons.com